afternoon dreams

Share this post
#58 - on the decision to co-live
himabatavia.substack.com

#58 - on the decision to co-live

And the laundry list of fears that come with it.

Hima Batavia
Feb 11
1
Share this post
#58 - on the decision to co-live
himabatavia.substack.com
The After Party Painting by Kelly Puissegur | Saatchi Art
The Afterparty // Artist Kelly Puissegur

If you value what you read and would like to support my work, consider Buying Me A Coffee, leaving a heart/comment on this post below, or sharing this journal with another human. If you’re not a subscriber yet, join us!

THANK YOU, LOVE YOU


My friend A says it is good for his mental health. S says it is less physical labour, but more emotional labour and K says everything is figure-outable. These are some of the conversations we have in the lead up to deciding to move into a co-living house with 6 other people in the west of Toronto.

In December, we go through an application process, detailing everything from how we tend to make decisions, how we intend to spend our time inside and outside of the house, and what skills we can bring to the community. I share that I am introverted and can be moody, but down to throw all the themed parties; a contradiction that satisfies my astrology. While in Helsinki, we jump on Zoom with the house for two hours, trying to get a sense of whether we could live together; whether we want to live together.

Food is at the top of C’s mind - a topic that has sometimes meant weekend-long retreats for the house to figure out how to mindfully and sustainably buy and dispose of the shared food model, while meeting everyone’s needs for comfort, pleasure and dietary preferences. S tells me a gardener will be coming to the house over the summer to teach everyone how to grow their own food. This is collaborative work that seems daunting, but also crucial if we want to put a tiny foot forward towards re-wilding and healing the land from decades of extraction. My spirit lights up.

I share all of my fears, and there is a laundry list. Will I be able to sleep? How will I have friends over? Will there ever be silence? Is there a cue for the shower? At the top of my list is an existential question about what it means to be an adult, and how to find the confidence to live your own script. Making smart speculative investment decisions and getting into the housing market before it’s too late are two sentences that play in my mind like a form of torture. Are we making a mistake by not doing so, and will I regret this?

At the same time that the conversation around co-living has grown, Toronto has become the priciest and most fiercely competitive real estate market in Canada, with the average home selling for $1.260M. In two decades, prices have increased by 490%, and are expected to go up by another 12% this year alone. Some are calling it a crisis housing bubble, that will cause misery and ruin if it crashes, but the Bank of Canada contends that it is not so. The FOMO of entering the market has led to a rise of what economist, Benjamin Tal, calls using the bank of mom and dad to firepower offers and competing bids. My dad tells me he wants to help. He is nervous we won’t be settled or have a place to live before he passes. Every week I get emails and Whatsapp messages of listings.

Many have accepted that the housing market has become out of reach or they simply refuse to carry a hefty mortgage for a 1-bedroom condo, instead choosing to focus on alternative investment opportunities. We rarely refer to community and care as investment opportunities, even though we hope for an ROI from the risk of love and the cost of time that we pour into them. Commercial developers are becoming increasingly interested in meeting the ‘millennial demand’ for co-living, who are simultaneously questioning everything from relationships to work to housing to money; writing new narratives of meaning.

Everyone I tell that we are moving into a co-house is equally shocked and intrigued. Why would you do this? What is the purpose? I could never. The common assumption is that we have made this decision to save money, which also suggests that our shared definition of being wealthy is to have the right to private space and property. I take this personally, and an ancestral shame around wealth and worthiness wells in me so deeply, there are simply not enough tears to carry it. There are of course cost-savings to co-living given the economics of sharing, but it is not as much as one would perceive.

Would I buy a big old fancy house if I could afford it? Probably. I’m not judgemental of this decision, because we are living in bardo times, the place in-between stories and scripts. The middle class especially can post about anti-capitalism in one breath, support an affordable housing strategy in another, read a book about genocide and stolen land, and hope their stock investments triple at the same time. This confusing existence, of figuring out how to live and embody the radical dreams we speak of, like housing justice, will be a defining marker of this era. It means that some will have to model a different way; an additional way. Because an actual transformation of housing in urban cities would mean building a market outside of speculation and expropriating private land for public use and Indigenous stewardship, which is equally impossible to imagine in the current state, and also entirely possible considering the levels of instability we are playing with.

When I tell my parents about our decision, they don’t say much. My mom grew up in a ‘joint family’ with her father’s sibling and their family - a common living arrangement amongst Indian families. Even after my parents were married, they lived with my paternal grandparents for many years. When they left the UK for Toronto and bought their own single-family home, it was an act of subverting the extended family structure to pursue their own ambitions and care for their mental health even though the trade-off meant cutting off support and intergenerational exchange.

David Brooks chronicles the history of the decentralization of the family in his piece, The nuclear family was a mistake. He shares how as the pace of life sped up, family loyalty was exchanged for privacy, convenience and mobility, ushering in the single dwelling nuclear family structure, which is typically two parents with two children constantly living on the edge of balancing full lives. The fragility of the nuclear family, Brooks argues, then led to further fragmentation, into ‘single-parent families, single-parent families into chaotic families or no families.’ He summarizes the change in family structure as this:

We’ve made life freer for individuals and more unstable for families. We’ve made life better for adults but worse for children. We’ve moved from big, interconnected, and extended families, which helped protect the most vulnerable people in society from the shocks of life, to smaller, detached nuclear families (a married couple and their children), which give the most privileged people in society room to maximize their talents and expand their options. The shift from bigger and interconnected extended families to smaller and detached nuclear families ultimately led to a familial system that liberates the rich and ravages the working-class and the poor.

Co-living in contemporary times is a return to the ‘extended family’ but the difference is captured within the choice and intention to pursue it, versus having to endure it within the confines of cultural obligation. Within the choice is ideally the opportunity for relational growth from addressing conflict in healthy ways, setting boundaries and communicating needs, instead of simply biting one’s tongue until it severs whole. In some ways, this decision feels calculated within the DNA of my lineage as an enduring value for community, closeness and intimacy. I am fascinated by the ways the pendulum swings across generations. Perhaps, we stay the same as we evolve.

Despite this extensive period of processing and deciding, I am freaking out. This past weekend I call an emergency meeting with some of my new roommates. I have stayed up late reading Jennifer Seniors piece, Why your friends will break your heart, where she reflects on the brutal pain of friendships dissolving, and the ways in which this relationship that is often referred to ‘as beneficial to your health as giving up cigarettes,’ is increasingly fragile in a world where everyone is running in different directions. ‘One could argue that modern life conspires against friendship,’ Seniors shares.

I have written about the friendship renaissance, and even was on the Life Without Us podcast (who not coincidentally is led by one of the founders of this co-house!) to dig deeper, and still, I wonder, how close is too close? The language of ‘chosen family’ has become popular, especially amongst queer communities, but my therapist reminds me of the dangers of projecting family roles on friendships. ‘If our friends become our substitute families, they pay for the failures of our families of origin,’ Seniors writes. It’s not surprising that we seek friendships that emulate our early imprinting, as we do in marriages according to Freud, but if not acknowledged, it can go horribly awry.

I know there will be conflict while co-living. I am scared about my capacity to face it, to transform it, to not let the weight of it destroy me or my friendships. Will my conflict skills improve or fail me? I fear my hypersensitivity and how I assume anyone who is mad at me will leave me. The risk-reward ratio is high and I am not aloof about this. Yet, in the midst of my meltdown, I am reminded of what could await me on the other side: new rituals, more intimacy, shared labour, and the love generated from co-creating. I remember that relationships are not ensured - they never can be, and if something is to break, it will. Co-living or not.

We have committed to trying it for a year. ‘I can do anything for a year,’ I boast. ‘It will make for some good writing,’ I joke-ish. Stepping into the unknown is always terrifying, but we do it because we know there is something there for us, even if we don’t know exactly what it is. I am excited to find out, even though it scares me to death.

Much love,

Hima

Thank you for reading afternoon dreams. This post is public so feel free to share it.

Share


#ThisWeekinTweets

Twitter avatar for @galdemzinegal-dem @galdemzine
A glimpse into the lives of transgender people in Kashmir
gal-dem.com/lives-of-trans…

February 11th 2022

1 Retweet1 Like
Twitter avatar for @iconicvinesChanukah Lewinsky @iconicvines
Imagine Dr. Phil running at you full speed

February 10th 2022

6,018 Retweets63,500 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NegoTrueNego True @NegoTrue
My wife just walked past me in our home and said “you haven’t asked me to be your Valentine uno? Men just be assuming things” ?????????????

February 3rd 2022

7,109 Retweets54,091 Likes
Twitter avatar for @chris_ryatesOsric the Flop @chris_ryates
was reading about the silent film era and thinking about how silly the word "talkie" is, and was then forced to really consider, for the first time, the word "movie"

February 10th 2022

14,017 Retweets157,491 Likes
Twitter avatar for @BreeNewsomeWe Can Build A Better World 🕊 @BreeNewsome
When we say “we need more affordable housing, healthcare & debt forgiveness” and the government response is “no, we will increase police spending instead” that is one of the most blatant examples of modern structural racism. But liberals keep normalizing it & ignoring the data.

February 5th 2022

2,918 Retweets13,884 Likes
Twitter avatar for @JessicaCalarcoJess Calarco @JessicaCalarco
Me: I barely got anything done this week. 7-year-old: What do you mean? You were in all those meetings. Me: Meetings are where work gets created, not where work gets done.

February 5th 2022

212 Retweets3,174 Likes
Twitter avatar for @PKhakpourporochista khakpour پوروچیستا خاکپور @PKhakpour
do you guys remember this trash candy? was there a single person who liked these? show yourselves
Image

February 5th 2022

418 Retweets9,351 Likes
Twitter avatar for @wgmi420wgmi @wgmi420
@TurnerNovak
Image

February 5th 2022

14 Retweets513 Likes
Twitter avatar for @bdmcclayBDM @bdmcclay
marriage… a sacred institution meant to redistribute wealth from a man in finance to a woman in the arts

February 5th 2022

1,696 Retweets24,807 Likes
Twitter avatar for @BreeNewsomeWe Can Build A Better World 🕊 @BreeNewsome
This is an incredible reflection of how a society comes to normalize mass death.

southpaw @nycsouthpaw

NYT May 24, 2020: U.S. Deaths Near 100,000, An Incalculable Loss NYT February 5, 2022: 900,000 Dead, but Many Americans Move On https://t.co/CfRccN7ijy

February 5th 2022

5,243 Retweets17,809 Likes
Twitter avatar for @1followernodadSophia Benoit @1followernodad
When you need ibuprofen and a safety pin and an extra pair of socks bc yours got wet do NOT come to me if you have this attitude !!!!

Billz @BMazoya

Why do women pack as if they are fugitives on the run pls. Is a suitcase really necessary if you’re only staying somewhere for one night or two

February 5th 2022

606 Retweets5,146 Likes
Twitter avatar for @_megconleyMeg Conley @_megconley
An English professor emailed me. She’s teaching my Harper’s Bazaar piece. Wanted to know if she could record a Zoom interview to share with her classes. AND SHE OFFERED TO PAY FOR CHILDCARE DURING THE INTERVIEW. Could you imagine if everyone was so considerate. She’s my hero.

February 6th 2022

808 Retweets25,459 Likes
Twitter avatar for @ginnyhogan_Ginny Hogan_ @ginnyhogan_
Nothing more impressive than someone who wears jeans alone at home

February 6th 2022

1,692 Retweets47,032 Likes
Twitter avatar for @clhubesLucy Huber @clhubes
Why is the theme of couples figure skating always “we are in love and this is our passion in dance form”. Why couldn’t it be “we just robbed a bank together and this is how we are escaping! But we’re just friends.”

February 7th 2022

1,382 Retweets17,306 Likes
Twitter avatar for @abolition_pressAbolitionist Voices @abolition_press
What abolition is, by @rwgilmoregirls
Image

January 22nd 2022

31 Retweets128 Likes
Twitter avatar for @thatclarafiedClara @thatclarafied
We need more working class writers in the room. If I have to watch one more storyline about the poor kid using their "emergency credit card" on a cute outfit I will become a menace to society

February 7th 2022

6,748 Retweets81,622 Likes
Twitter avatar for @janetheeesqJane, Esq. @janetheeesq
my dad just called me to tell me he went viral on twitter. he was deadass. i asked him how many likes he got. he said 30.

February 7th 2022

13,800 Retweets282,148 Likes
Twitter avatar for @cristela9Cristela Alonzo @cristela9
NOT A JOKE: Spotify CEO pledges to invest $100m in content from marginalized groups. Doubles down on JR and they would, they spent a lot of money on him BUT...the balls this guy has to say he'll split THE SAME AMOUNT HE PAID ONE GUY TO MARGINALIZED GROUPS IS EVEN WORSE.

February 7th 2022

2,306 Retweets19,492 Likes
Twitter avatar for @TheSuperiorPinkmiles @TheSuperiorPink
this can’t be the future dippin dots was the ice cream of

February 7th 2022

16,463 Retweets123,453 Likes
Twitter avatar for @amandamullAmanda Mull @amandamull
Here’s a thought experiment I’ve been doing: do I really want to upend my life or is it just winter

February 9th 2022

1,601 Retweets20,582 Likes
Twitter avatar for @jzuxtrash jones @jzux
trust my gut? the thing that can’t even handle milk?

February 9th 2022

57,495 Retweets341,436 Likes
Twitter avatar for @devvvthebanddev @devvvtheband
Not having had covid yet is starting to feel like a new type of virginity

February 9th 2022

35,200 Retweets315,239 Likes
Twitter avatar for @everywhereistGeraldine @everywhereist
My doctor and I were discussing my anxiety and she said "Brains are made to keep us alive. They're not made to keep us happy." And I can't stop thinking about that.

February 10th 2022

15,133 Retweets112,517 Likes
Twitter avatar for @MonsterVetArtMacK @MonsterVetArt
Anti vaxxers : Don’t shut the country down because of mandates! Truckers: We’re shutting the country down because of mandates. #Clownvoy #TruckersConvoy

February 10th 2022

518 Retweets2,364 Likes
Twitter avatar for @cremebruleecartthe creme brûlée cart @cremebruleecart
San Francisco is in a bad way. Vibes are all effed up. I can’t do much to solve the problems here, but I can make pancakes. So I hung up fliers all over the neighborhood and made pancakes. Over 75 people came and over 125 pancakes were eaten. Here’s what I learned: 👇
Image

February 3rd 2022

632 Retweets5,407 Likes
Share this post
#58 - on the decision to co-live
himabatavia.substack.com
Comments

Create your profile

0 subscriptions will be displayed on your profile (edit)

Skip for now

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.

TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2022 Hima Batavia
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Publish on Substack Get the app
Substack is the home for great writing