afternoon dreams

Share this post
#63 - on moral choice
himabatavia.substack.com

#63 - on moral choice

And too many parking tickets.

Hima Batavia
Mar 25
Share this post
#63 - on moral choice
himabatavia.substack.com

If you value what you read and would like to support my work, consider Buying Me A Coffee, leaving a heart/comment on this post below, or sharing this journal with another human. If you’re not a subscriber yet, join us!

THANK YOU, LOVE YOU.


#HimaWritesPoetry

the living dead

there was no funeral or flowers

when you died while

sitting right beside me

-

I could still hear you breathing

but no longer knew why

you exhaled like the

morning tide

-

it all happened so fast in

slow motion I watched it

while sitting inside of it kind of

like an oysters pearl

-

when we left for the crowds,

I sent out a signal with my

heart’s eye, like we use to

-

but no one caught it and

it evaporated into the

twilight and evening tide

-

we grieve the living more than the

dead but there are

no funerals or flowers


By the time I graduated from university, I had about $1000 of unpaid parking tickets. I was a commuter, travelling from Markham to Downtown Toronto almost every day. For the first two years, I would drive 40 minutes to Finch Station, park my parent’s car in the lot, and then take the subway for another 30 minutes; making the round trip about an hour and 15 minutes. I would often take this daily trip with my friend A, both of us sleep-deprived and outfitted in oversized sweatpants, parkas and backpacks stuffed with biology textbooks.

Our first stop after docking at St. George station would be the Tim Hortons at the corner to order a double-double and carrot bran muffin - almost as a reward for the long journey. I figured the ‘bran’ muffin was the least nutritionally offensive option on the menu until one day I looked at the caloric information brochure sitting beside the napkins and found out it had 22g of fat in it.

As year three rolled around, my patience and time management skills severely declined and shaving off 15-20 minutes from the commute in the dead of winter felt like the difference between getting an education and dropping out. I would drive downtown and spend all the money I was making working as a research assistant and at a Rogers call centre on parking and gas. The cost felt ‘worth it’ at the time since foresight was not accessible as a surviving student who had the privilege of accessing a car.

Back then, there were no apps for parking meters. You had to physically walk up to a machine, enter your credit card and wait for a ticket to be printed to display on your dashboard. Most meters had a three-hour maximum, sometimes two - meaning you would have to run back to the car in-between classes, labs and club meetings on a sprawling campus at the exact minute the time ran out to refill the meter. The logistics made no sense but the small comfort that the car offered overruled all rationale.

On-campus, parking attendants were everywhere. They would walk up and down small streets, monitoring a handful of cars for transgressions on their tickets. Often, it seemed like you had a 60-second window to refill your parking meter before getting dinged with a $30-50 ticket. Sometimes you would get lucky - which tricked your brain into thinking that you could risk a few extra minutes before running back to reload. Other times, you were just lazy, lost track of time or reticent to keep spending money.

On one particular day, I had to take a three-hour exam. I knew I would not be able to park, get to the exam on time, and make it back within a three-hour window. I paid my dues and then decided to write a note to the parking attendant to leave on my dashboard. ‘Have a 3-hour exam. Will come back right after to fill up. Please don’t ticket me!’ When I returned, exhausted, a yellow ticket fluttered on my windshield wipers. In the short distance, I could see the attendant, wearing sunglasses and a navy uniform, walking away coolly with his ticketing device.

I was livid. Had he not read my note? I wrote a note for god’s sake! Why didn’t he understand my situation?

Instead of taking a few mindful breaths, or crying from feeling out of control, I marched down the street and confronted the parking attendant. Why did you give me a ticket? I had an exam! What do you expect me to do? I wrote you a note! I pleaded my case exasperatedly and aggressively. He said nothing and walked away.

‘What a loser,’ I thought - as my amateur mind spiralled into vilifying this stranger. I made up all kinds of stories about how powerless and inadequate this man must have felt in his life — needing to use parking tickets as a way to have power and control over others. I foolishly held on to this anger for years because I assumed that parking attendants could make a moral choice - and the ‘morally correct’ decision was to give people some grace. To have some humanity and realize we are all trying to do our best. At least according to my definition.

Generally, the most common response to me complaining about parking is ‘if you don’t like it, don’t drive.’ And that is legitimate in that we need guidelines in order to coexist and share space. If the attendant is to consider my specific situation - then what is the line on when they should give grace or not? How can they ever justify their actions to their superiors? Should they have to?

My anger is often a function of not agreeing or understanding what the guidelines optimize for and what the intention, incentives and politics are behind a decision. Are parking costs meant to dissuade people from driving towards supporting a legitimate shared value for the land and environment, protect private property or maximize revenue to prop up police budgets? In 2019 alone, the City of Toronto collected ~$60 million dollars in revenue from parking due to a ‘higher than planned ticket issuance.’

I recently read an article about Ander Cohen’s work - who is a conflict resolution expert based in Illinois and the co-founder of the Civic Leadership Foundation. He facilitates difficult conversations and negotiations with people across all kinds of organizations, from hospitals and gangs to those seeking peace in conflict zones. While working with Chicago’s Cook County Jail, which has more than 6,500 inmates to facilitate a discussion on how to support people being released from prison and preventing re-entry - a conversation Cohen notes as one of the toughest he has ever led - he asked a reluctant corrections officer, ‘what do people get wrong about what you do?’ or said another way, ‘how are you misunderstood?’ The officer immediately attuned to the question and responded, ‘people think that I feel normal about this, keeping people in cages all day. There is nothing normal about my job.’

When I think about the parking attendant now - almost 20 years later - I realize how little choice they might have had to make a ‘moral decision,’ even if they wanted to. The risk of rejecting dominant systems, rules and guidelines are increasingly high in an interconnected system, where your finances and reputation are closely tied together. Making a ‘moral choice’ can be the difference between having what you need to feel safe: food, heat, water, shelter, community care, respect, trust. Having choice can be empowering - but not having nuance between what choices are genuinely available to us at this moment is violent.

And yet, every day we are bombarded with messaging to make individual moral choices to ‘save the world,’ from what we buy, to what we share online, to who we work for, to where we donate to, to what kind of straw and coffee cup we use and on and on. It is exhausting and cruel to put any individual under so much moral responsibility within an emphatically immoral system that continues to exist primarily to protect and monetize private property.

The parking attendant taking a stance alone is a risky proposition - but thousands of parking attendants advocating together is systemic change. The moral courage of an individual can have a ripple effect - but collective action is the only safe and sustainable way we can all participate in reimagining how we live and relate to one another in a way that does not force people into lives that feel so disconnected from what they know to be true to them. We don’t have to agree on everything, but we have to agree on some things beyond profit maximization and individual success and freedom as the only purpose of human existence. A good example of this work happening in real-time despite corporate resistance is workers in nearly 100 Starbucks around the US unionizing to secure higher wages and mental health care benefits.

A reminder to myself is to be mindful of slipping into judging the individual actions of the everyday person - recognizing that if our systems won’t give us grace, let’s try to give some to each other some while focusing on rallying around the bigger picture.

Hima

Leave a comment


#ThisWeekinTweets

Twitter avatar for @LolotovCLola, Enby ENVTuber @LolotovC
@ToughOnInternet @DrDrAbhiKole
Image

March 21st 2022

167 Retweets5,492 Likes
Twitter avatar for @theslowfactorySlow Factory @theslowfactory
We’re told again and again that we would need to make huge, painful sacrifices to save the planet. But what if those sacrifices meant working less, slowing down, living a better life as well?

March 24th 2022

338 Retweets1,889 Likes
Twitter avatar for @AlexAndBooks_Alex & Books 📚 @AlexAndBooks_
I asked, "What’s the BEST documentary you’ve ever seen?" I received 1,500+ responses. Here are 25 documentaries that will entertain and educate you:

March 24th 2022

2,031 Retweets9,504 Likes
Twitter avatar for @nvtvxoNatalie @nvtvxo
Just saw a reel that said staying home is good for anxiety and bad for depression and going out is good for depression and bad for anxiety, so I’m going to stand halfway out my door and let my brain have an overload of emotions 😭

March 23rd 2022

45,827 Retweets257,781 Likes
Twitter avatar for @_radsyRads @_radsy
“always the bridesmaid, never the bride” damn sorry to hear that multiple people consider you a good friend

March 25th 2022

7,933 Retweets158,172 Likes
Twitter avatar for @tashakaminskypassover hate account @tashakaminsky
when i was 15 my mother's jewelry was stolen. the cops were really into the angle that i had sold the jewelry for drugs to throw a party. my mother looked at me wistfully and said no, she couldn't throw a party to save her life. she hasn't even figured out her hair.

March 23rd 2022

6,307 Retweets148,971 Likes
Twitter avatar for @thehotyoungmomDee 💖 @thehotyoungmom
did y’all know it takes 18-24 months, on average, for someone to start to heal after a significant loss? 2 whole years

March 23rd 2022

28,473 Retweets234,196 Likes
Twitter avatar for @JenBassAllenJBA @JenBassAllen
What does Love mean to 4-8 year old kids? A thread… A group of professional people posed this question to a group of 4 to 8 year-olds, 'What does love mean?' The answers they got were broader, deeper, and more profound than anyone could have ever imagined!

March 22nd 2022

31,049 Retweets92,581 Likes
Twitter avatar for @nikillinitNikhil Krishnan @nikillinit
“We’re cutting out the middleman” - a company that is now the middleman

March 22nd 2022

684 Retweets7,385 Likes
Twitter avatar for @ashleyn1coleAshley Nicole Black @ashleyn1cole
One of the cool things they don't tell you about your thirties is you can hurt your neck by turning to look at something, which is wild because that is neck's main job.

March 22nd 2022

6,562 Retweets83,925 Likes
Twitter avatar for @dereckapurnellderecka @dereckapurnell
i believe in love so much. we should be able to enter and exit relationships on our own terms. I believe love is best when coupled with agency. I believe that we can love best when we aren’t in relationships for survival, for housing, for healthcare. We deserve that kind of love

February 14th 2022

2,960 Retweets17,047 Likes
Twitter avatar for @walkercaplwalker @walkercapl
Nonfiction is crazy…… you’re telling me you know what happened to you?

March 21st 2022

2,722 Retweets44,090 Likes
Twitter avatar for @jlazebnikJohnny LaZebnik @jlazebnik
one of the craziest parts of hollywood is learning that most celebrity’s email addresses are like, cateblanchett @ gmail . com

March 21st 2022

1,848 Retweets75,518 Likes
Twitter avatar for @baddanadanabaddana bad @baddanadanabad
when men are insecure? ew. but when men are confident? also ew… not sure what their path forward is.

March 22nd 2022

3,467 Retweets55,917 Likes
Twitter avatar for @wtfdiprataylor's version @wtfdipra
unlearning liberalism is realising that you can’t cancel people irl, at least not over the smaller things. radicalisation requires conversation.

March 20th 2022

483 Retweets4,049 Likes
Twitter avatar for @PleaseBeGneissslate @PleaseBeGneiss
tomorrow is promised to no one. don’t meal prep

March 21st 2022

9,509 Retweets91,493 Likes
Twitter avatar for @govindajeggySanjeev Kohli @govindajeggy
When I said butter, I actually meant ghee. I should have clarified

March 19th 2022

3,291 Retweets43,533 Likes
Twitter avatar for @rivbutcherriver indiana 3/25 & 3/26 butcher 🤠 @rivbutcher
“No one said life was going to be easy.” - the people who make a shitload of money making life hard for other people

March 20th 2022

4,148 Retweets40,746 Likes
Twitter avatar for @benjancewiczBenjamin Young Savage (ᐱᓐᒋᐱᓐ) @benjancewicz
Russian troops form a mob to arrest teenager Olga Misik while she reads Article 31 of the Russian constitution that guarantees the right to a peaceful protest.
Image

March 20th 2022

38,545 Retweets190,554 Likes
Twitter avatar for @DanaSchwartzzzDana Schwartz 🫀 @DanaSchwartzzz
what if.... instead of dealing with the root of the situations I need to address.... I just bought things

March 20th 2022

7,598 Retweets51,338 Likes
Twitter avatar for @HannahntheWolfhannah imogen starflower ♿️ @HannahntheWolf
Explaining how much I have to sleep to my nondisabled or even my disabled but non-chronically ill colleagues is always hilarious because they *never* believe how much I have to fucking sleep.

March 21st 2022

492 Retweets5,499 Likes
Twitter avatar for @myelasticheart_my elastic heart ❤️‍🔥♿️ @myelasticheart_
i don't know who needs to hear this today, but you are not indestructible. Studies show somewhere between 20-50% of people who catch COVID will develop long COVID, a chronic illness with heart, lung, & neurological complications. Is that a risk you really want to take?

March 20th 2022

45 Retweets159 Likes
Twitter avatar for @LilyYilyLily Sullivan @LilyYily
my love language is cooking elaborate meals screaming at everyone to get out of the kitchen then loudly announcing the food was NOT MY BEST and waiting for compliments

March 20th 2022

47,319 Retweets383,112 Likes
Twitter avatar for @rachsymerachel syme @rachsyme
the world is on fire so why not tell me about the best scented candle you've ever burned

March 21st 2022

1,954 Retweets38,784 Likes
Twitter avatar for @myeshachoumyesha thee stallion @myeshachou
bella hadid’s saying that she wished she kept the nose of her ancestors makes me think of the quote that your existence is proof that generations of your face has been loved

March 20th 2022

24,685 Retweets222,137 Likes
Twitter avatar for @curlycomedyAbbi Crutchfield @curlycomedy
I honestly think we are asking too much of cauliflower.

March 20th 2022

15,542 Retweets194,529 Likes
Twitter avatar for @HollyBallantineHolly Ballantine @HollyBallantine
My daughter said she can’t wait to have kids. I asked her why and she said “so they can bring me stuff when it’s in another room.”

March 19th 2022

16,652 Retweets268,706 Likes
Share this post
#63 - on moral choice
himabatavia.substack.com
Comments

Create your profile

0 subscriptions will be displayed on your profile (edit)

Skip for now

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.

TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2022 Hima Batavia
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Publish on Substack Get the app
Substack is the home for great writing